Reviews

 
Recommend
Trust
Listening
 
Written by a NHS patient at Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh
19th March 2022


I agree with the patient above. He never explains anything, I had a life changing surgery and he never told me how disabling it would be. I had bone cancer and he diagnosed me over the phone, never even explained properly what type of cancer I had, he left all the explanations to my oncologist. My leg never functioned properly, I have conditions that could be resolved with surgery but for years he lied to me saying that those surgeries were not a possibility. I stopped seeing him a while ago because it was like talking to a wall and I started to meet other bone cancer patients and noticed how they get help from the surgeons to improve the quality of their lives. He never elaborates his answers, didn't explain anything about my post op and what is a lot worse, he noticed that my endoprosthetic was loose and never said anything, to not commit to a revision. I'm still trying to get answers about my case, the early loosening of my prosthetic could have been caused by an infection, I'm praying to find someone to help me with the mess that this man left in my leg, my knee is completely stiff and he declined to do a manipulation or anything to help me, also he never told me about risks associated with the extensor mechanism. I was left unfit for work at 29 years old, with a disabled child to look after that will need care for the rest of his life. I can't get benefits and live below the poverty line as my capacity for work is very limited, no one would give me a job and now I have to try to do some freelance work, that is very badly paid and I can't say that I have a steady income. I had to go back into education because I relied on my legs for my livelihood. I would not want surgery from him and trusting him in the past is the biggest regret of my life.

Recommend
Trust
Listening
 
Written by a NHS patient at Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh
17th February 2021


Within three months I had two small surgery procedures, each lasting 20 minutes, in an operating theatre, under local anesthetic. During both I was awake. The first was at Dermatology. It went well. The second was in Orthopaedics with Mr Moran. When the operation was finished Mr Moran lapsed into an ill temper. He frowned, grimaced and eventually walked off without saying goodbye. In a subsequent email I tried to find out what this had been about. He did not explain. The operating theatre is a daunting place for a patient, with bleeping equipment and strange faces. An even-tempered, articulate surgeon would have been desirable. During a subsequent consultation Mr Moran told me about a complex operation which I may need in the short to medium term. He also recommended that I see a rheumatologist. The rheumatology professor warned me that this operation did not always have a satisfactory outcome and that I should postpone it as long as possible or go without it altogether. I am appalled that Mr Moran had not mentioned these risks. How am I supposed to make an informed decision without knowing the odds? I have audio-recordings of my consultations with Mr Moran. I remain grateful to the rheumatology professor for explaining the risks. Mr Moran has been burdensome. I would not want surgery from him again.

Recommend
Trust
Listening
 
 

Specialises in

  • Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery